More and more people these days are rediscovering the merits of an old-school shave with a traditional razor. And it’s not just because it looks cool (although it does).
Shaving with a straight razor offers a closeness that can’t be matched by other razors. And many people enjoy the ritual of the process, which allows them to carve a little quiet time out of an otherwise hectic daily schedule.
The traditional method of shaving is also more environmentally friendly. By using the same razor over and over, you keep a mountain of plastic disposable blades out of the landfill.
But shaving in this way requires the right equipment. And one piece of equipment that is often overlooked is the humble shaving scuttle.
At its most basic, a scuttle is a small bowl or dish that is used to keep the lather warm. However, the scuttle you choose can make a significant difference to the pleasure of shaving.
So let’s take a look at some of the best shaving scuttles currently on the market.
The 5 Best Shaving Scuttles
Table of Contents
- 1 The 5 Best Shaving Scuttles
- 2 1. Georgetown Pottery G12 Shaving Scuttle Mug
- 3 2. Sara Bonnyman Pottery Slate Moss Scuttle
- 4 3. Crown King Porcelain Shave Scuttle
- 5 4. Shavebowl Modular Shaving Bowl and Scuttle
- 6 5. Schone Stainless Steel Shaving Bowl
- 7 Factors To Consider Before Buying A Shaving Scuttle
- 8 Our Final Take
|Georgetown Pottery G12 Shaving Scuttle Mug|
|Sara Bonnyman Pottery Slate Moss Scuttle|
|Crown King Porcelain Shave Scuttle|
|Shavebowl Modular Shaving Bowl and Scuttle|
|Schone Stainless Steel Shaving Bowl|
The craftsmanship on this scuttle is immediately apparent. The 12 oz water reservoir keeps the lather warm even through the longest of shaves. A pewter stopper allows for the reservoir to be covered, preventing spills and keeping the lather hot even longer.
The G12 is quite a large shaving scuttle, and this size allows it to act as a shaving mug too. Instead of needing to keep the soap elsewhere, you can use the G12 to store your soap and create your lather. This large scuttle can actually save you some precious counter space.
The Opal finish of the G12 makes it an attractive item to keep on your bathroom countertop. It also helps to protect the ceramic from chips and scratches.
The ceramic of the G12 holds heat well, and should keep the lather warm even through the longest of shaves. And this shaving scuttle is even dishwasher safe, which makes it a breeze to keep clean.
It’s honestly hard to find anything bad to say about the G12. As a ceramic scuttle, it is vulnerable to being dropped, so clumsy shavers might want to stay away. But otherwise, the G12 shaving scuttle makes for a great shave.
Sara Bonnyman scuttles are handmade, so no two are exactly alike. This is a scuttle that is made to take pride of place in your bathroom.
The heavyweight clay holds in the heat of the water to keep your lather warm. And the roughened texture of the surface introduces a lot of air to create a rich and foamy lather.
These scuttles take a month to make, and each one is hand-crafted by Sara Bonnyman. As a result, they can take some time to acquire, and they don’t come cheap.
One interesting feature is that instead of a spout, this scuttle has a small slit to pour away the water when finished. This helps keep the heat from escaping.
The scuttle is large enough to make lather for more than a single shave, so this is a piece that often finds itself in use in barber shops and other commercial uses.
3. Crown King Porcelain Shave Scuttle
The all-white appearance of this shaving scuttle gives it a classic and clean look that should fit into almost any bathroom. And the porcelain material offers great heat retention to keep that lather warm.
The Crown King has a rubber stopper that you remove in order to pour in hot water. The porcelain then transmits the heat of the water into the lather, keeping it nice and warm.
The inside of this shaving scuttle has deep grooves in both horizontal and vertical surfaces. These grooves help the formation of thicker lather as you swirl the brush around.
The rubber stopper can even be replaced while the scuttle is full of water, making the heat retention even better. But due to the narrow opening of the water chamber, you won’t be able to use the water to keep your brush wet while shaving.
While porcelain offers great heat retention, it is a notoriously fragile material. If you’re a clumsy person or your bathroom is particularly cramped, this shaving scuttle may not be the best option for you. Drop the Crown king to the floor, and it’s unlikely to survive.
With all that said, this shaving scuttle has a lot to recommend it. If treated with care, it should provide years of useful service.
The Shavebowl is made from a polymer that contains 40% clay minerals. This textured polymer feels like soapstone to the touch. But it offers greater durability than porcelain or ceramic bowls.
The textured interior creates a nice rich lather. And the clean lines will fit in with any modern, minimalist bathroom.
The Shavebowl is really two bowls that can be used as a scuttle by filling the bottom bowl with hot water. The top bowl also has carefully designed notches to hold your razor and brush, adding to the space saving appeal of this set.
Made of shiny and reflective stainless steel, this offering from Schone couldn’t look more modern. And unlike more traditional shaving scuttles, it doesn’t make use of a water reservoir to keep lather hot.
However, steel doesn’t hold heat well. While this item does come with a lid to help it retain heat, it won’t keep lather warm as well as some other shaving scuttles.
Sleek looks and durability make this bowl a good option in tight spaces. But those who make more of a ritual of their shaving may want something that holds heat better and looks more traditional.
Factors To Consider Before Buying A Shaving Scuttle
Scuttle Vs. Mug
It’s possible to use a mug to hold the lather for your shave. There are many shaving mugs available for this purpose, and some people are happy using a simple coffee mug.
These mugs may offer an old-time feel, but they are actually a recent invention. For a truly authentic straight razor shave, a scuttle is far more appropriate. Besides, a mug won’t keep the lather warm for you the way a proper scuttle will.
Think carefully about the way that you shave. Like many decisions, this one will come down to personal preference.
Some people like to have enough room to swirl the brush around inside the scuttle without touching the sides. But this comes with a trade-off in the amount of space the scuttle takes up. In modern bathrooms, space can often be hard to come by.
Make sure you choose a shaving scuttle that will fit in your bathroom without taking up space you need for other things.
For many people, part of the appeal of a traditional shave is the way all the necessary equipment looks. A good shaving set can certainly contribute to a striking look in your bathroom.
Stainless steel scuttles are extremely durable. Immune to moisture and corrosion and able to be dropped without damage, these scuttles will last forever. However, steel offers very poor heat retention compared to other materials.
Your lather will cool more slowly in a porcelain scuttle. These also offer a very traditional look but are extremely fragile.
Ceramic scuttles hold heat better than steel but not as well as porcelain, and aren’t as easy to break. That doesn’t make them immune to being dropped, however. They can also acquire chips and scratched over time.
Wood shaving scuttles are available too, and they retain heat better than steel. But in a humid environment like a bathroom, they may not last as long as other options.
If you’re just starting out with this method of shaving, it might be a good idea to avoid spending too much money all at once. A cheaper shaving scuttle will allow you to try things out and make sure that this is the way you want to shave.
But if you’re already sold on the benefits of a straight razor shave, consider getting a shaving scuttle that will look nicer with your other shave equipment and serve you better. A higher price doesn’t always mean better quality. But at the same time, the cheapest options are usually cheaper for a reason.
Our Final Take
A straight razor shave is an increasingly popular way for people to pamper themselves. The almost ritualistic nature of the process can transform a mundane task to the level of an art.
But the equipment you use can make a huge difference in how much you enjoy the process. Everyone understands that the razor they choose matters, but it’s less common to think about the other equipment you might need.
A decent shave can be had without a shaving scuttle. But you may be surprised to find how much luxury such a seemingly simple item adds to the process. And you may also be surprised by just how many options are out there.
Getting a job done correctly requires having the right tools. A shaving scuttle is a great idea for anyone who prefers to take a more deliberate approach to their personal care.
Let us know your favorite shaving gear in the comments!